John Sampogna, co-founder and CEO of Wondersauce, didn’t set out to build just another creative agency. Instead, he focused on solving real client problems, staying hyper-transparent, and scaling at a sustainable pace. In a recent episode of the Turning Pro Podcast, John sat down with hosts Adrian Alfieri and Ben Sharf to unpack the lessons he's learned from running a successful agency for over a decade. From strategic service expansion to maintaining work-life balance, John’s insights are a masterclass in building a resilient business.
For many agencies, growth is often reactive—clients request new services, and teams scramble to meet demand. But for John, scaling has always been about recognizing patterns and addressing gaps in the market with intention.
“If the same request keeps coming up from multiple clients, that’s a signal,” he explains. “It’s telling you there’s a gap in the market that people assume your agency should be filling.”
Rather than blindly chasing every opportunity, Wondersauce takes a measured approach. The team identifies in-house expertise, tests potential offerings with select clients (sometimes at discounted rates), and refines the service before rolling it out at scale. Transparency is key—clients appreciate honesty about what’s being tested and are often open to providing feedback in exchange for early access.
Growth isn’t just about adding more services—it’s about consistency. In the early days, John found himself overdelivering for clients, believing that going the extra mile would set Wondersauce apart. But as the agency scaled, he realized that clients valued something even more: predictability.
“Clients don’t need you to go above and beyond every single time,” he says. “What they really want is for you to tell them what you’re going to do—and then do exactly that, with great communication.”
This realization transformed Wondersauce’s operations. By defining clear expectations, maintaining streamlined communication channels, and focusing on delivering consistently high-quality work, the agency built lasting relationships with its clients. Whether it’s using Slack for daily touchpoints or structuring feedback loops via email, every process is designed for efficiency and clarity.
Early on, there was a perception that Wondersauce was only suited for startups and digitally native brands. But John and his team always had their sights set higher. A major turning point came when they competed against—and ultimately won a pitch against—large, traditional agencies for a major restaurant brand.
“That was the moment we realized we weren’t just a scrappy startup agency anymore,” he recalls. “It validated that our way of doing things worked at the highest level.”
This win proved that Wondersauce could compete with industry giants while maintaining its distinct approach. More importantly, it set the stage for future growth, as larger clients began taking the agency seriously.
Staying in the agency game for over a decade requires discipline—not just in execution but in decision-making. John has always been wary of what he calls “shiny object syndrome,” where agency founders get distracted by new opportunities that don’t align with their core business.
“An agency needs 100% of your focus to be great. If you want to build a product, that needs 100% of your focus too,” he explains. “Trying to do both is where a lot of people get stuck.”
Instead of branching into unrelated ventures, John has stayed committed to refining and strengthening Wondersauce. This focus has allowed the agency to maintain its creative edge while continuing to grow in a competitive landscape.
In many entrepreneurs’ eyes, selling a business is the ultimate milestone. For John, however, selling Wondersauce wasn’t about cashing out—it was about finding the right partner to support the agency’s long-term vision. In 2017, Wondersauce was acquired by Project Worldwide, a company known for allowing its agencies to operate independently.
“Most founders leave after an acquisition,” he says. “But six years later, I’m still here because I believe in what we’re building.”
Unlike many acquisitions where culture gets diluted, Wondersauce has maintained its identity. John credits this to Project Worldwide’s hands-off approach, which allows agency leaders to keep running their businesses without unnecessary interference.
One of the biggest lessons John has learned over the years is that business success means nothing without personal fulfillment. For him, that means maintaining a work-life balance that allows him to show up at his best every day. He’s structured his routine around early morning workouts, quality time with his family, and a clear separation between work and personal time.
“You have to put yourself in a position where you’re giving yourself the best chance to wake up every day feeling energized and clear-headed,” he says. “For me, that means working out in the morning, eating right, and making sure I have time for the things I care about outside of work.”
This approach has helped him sustain high performance for over a decade without burning out.
John’s journey offers a roadmap for agency founders and entrepreneurs looking to build something lasting:
For agency owners, creatives, and entrepreneurs, John’s insights serve as a reminder that scaling successfully isn’t about doing more—it’s about doing the right things with focus and intention.
Want to hear more from John Sampogna? Check out his full conversation on Turning Pro Podcast:
Please fill your information so we can get in touch with you.
Please fill your information so we can get in touch with you.
